2014-09-14 08:39:20

DNA@home, SubsetSum@home and Wildlife@home Where merged into one project called Citizen Science Grid with all the previus projects as subprojects. The previus atachment url's don't work anymore, and the new is http://volunteer.cs.und.edu/csg/

2014-09-14 13:36:30

victor_sueca wrote:

DNA@home, SubsetSum@home and Wildlife@home Where merged into one project called Citizen Science Grid with all the previus projects as subprojects. The previus atachment url's don't work anymore, and the new is http://volunteer.cs.und.edu/csg/

Users are encouraged to link their accounts from the subprojects into the CSG account.

HTH

2014-09-14 14:30:41

Augustine wrote:

victor_sueca wrote:

DNA@home, SubsetSum@home and Wildlife@home Where merged into one project called Citizen Science Grid with all the previus projects as subprojects. The previus atachment url's don't work anymore, and the new is http://volunteer.cs.und.edu/csg/

Users are encouraged to link their accounts from the subprojects into the CSG account.

HTH

Yeah, but i think that projects should be merged into CSG also in Boinc Stats. What does the users think about that?

2014-09-14 19:36:02

victor_sueca wrote:

Augustine wrote:

Users are encouraged to link their accounts from the subprojects into the CSG account.

HTH

Yeah, but i think that projects should be merged into CSG also in Boinc Stats. What does the users think about that?

I do not run any of the named projects but as a long time BOINC user that would make the most logical sense.
One project = One Stats Export regardless of how many sub-project.
Example: PrimeGrid has many sub-projects and includes in their stats the points of their external "sister"/sub-project PRPnet.

2014-09-15 00:13:02

2014-09-15 06:45:22

I was looking this mornig about the server status for CSG and i found 4 servers, 1 for each subproject and 1 for the CSG. DNA@home Server Status, Wildlife@home Server Status, SubsetSum@home Server Status and also Citizen Science Grid Server Status. The subproject servers are online but with its applications disabled, while the CSG server has its applications working. The question is... Why do they have a server online for each subproject if they already have a server that works with all them

2014-09-15 11:17:14

victor_sueca wrote:

The question is... Why do they have a server online for each subproject if they already have a server that works with all them

It are all subdirectories on the same server named Volunteer with the IP 134.129.213.31.

2014-09-15 12:24:12

2014-09-16 02:28:28
last modified: 2014-09-16 02:28:50

victor_sueca wrote:

Why do they have a server online for each subproject if they already have a server that works with all them

Because they were originally separate projects from the same university. They were just recently merged into the "Citizen Science Grid" and the old servers will be retired once the transition is complete.

Click here to see My Detailed BOINC Stats

2014-09-16 18:35:57

2014-10-01 00:17:47

[AF>France>TDM>Centrefranky82 wrote:

And now, we're waiting to Boincstats to only use the CSG stats !

Ehrr, frankly said: That's impossible, as CSG stats incorporates the old scores of three other projects and so is granting you a higher total score than you have actually crunched. The CSG stats should be taken MINUS the old score(s) for the three projects.

2014-10-01 00:25:22

2014-10-01 07:07:05

Dirk Broer wrote:

Another soluition is to brake down the CSG stats into the scores for the old projects and add the credit to DNA@HOme, Wildlife@Home or SubsumSet@Home.

Make that break down instead of brake down

2014-10-01 07:24:58

2014-10-01 15:27:14

[BOINCstats Willy wrote:

DNA@HOme, Wildlife@Home and SubsumSet@Home will be retired and removed from the combined stats. On the same day Citizen Science Grid will be added and included in the combined stats.

In such cases when projects are merged together, would it make sense to automatically try to find the account and, if it was found, to sign up automatically and attach the hosts previously attached to any of the merged projects?

TIA.

2014-10-01 15:49:24

2014-10-05 06:57:15

2014-10-06 00:39:50

2014-10-08 22:40:23
last modified: 2014-10-08 22:40:49

Roadranner wrote:

In my opinion the CSG subprojects should not appear in the list of finished projects, because they aren't finished. Credits now appear two times.

No, they don't. Compare your scores in BOINCSTats to those in FreeDC. In FreeDC they *DO* appear two times at the moment, Willy has subtracted the points from the 'finished projects' from your total.

2014-10-09 07:52:54

Dirk Broer wrote:

Roadranner wrote:

In my opinion the CSG subprojects should not appear in the list of finished projects, because they aren't finished. Credits now appear two times.

No, they don't. Compare your scores in BOINCSTats to those in FreeDC. In FreeDC they *DO* appear two times at the moment, Willy has subtracted the points from the 'finished projects' from your total.

You're wrong, because counting together the finished projects is just the same as my credits at CSG!
The intention of CSG is to merge the projects (and the credits) and not to finish something!!!
Btw. there's no subproject of e.g. WCG, Primegrid, etc. listed in the finished projects.

2014-10-09 18:00:33

2014-10-10 06:54:13
last modified: 2014-10-10 06:54:40

2014-10-10 23:21:12
last modified: 2014-10-10 23:25:27

Before noting subprojects as finished:

My_combined_stats = My_projects + My_finished_projects

That's not equal with the present statistics:

My_combined_stats = My_projects + My_finished_projects - SubsetSum - DNA - Wildlife !!!


I like the seperate subproject list in FreeDC - there it makes sense to mark projects as finished or not, because it doesn't affect the main stats.

P.S. We should mail your brilliant idea about merging the CERN stats to their admins.

2014-10-17 13:38:46